Stock option planning: How to avoid costly equity mistakes
22 min
San Francisco native (yes, really). @uw and Lowell High alum. I like to nerd out on fintech, stock options and taxes.
0 result
0 result
San Francisco native (yes, really). @uw and Lowell High alum. I like to nerd out on fintech, stock options and taxes.
Equity with life-changing potential can still become a missed opportunity if you aren't sure:
How it could fit into your personal finances and goals
When to exercise your options and when to hold off
The actual cost to exercise (AMT and other taxes can come as a surprise)
If you can actually afford to exercise (non-recourse financing might help)
Stock option planning can't guarantee that your equity will pay off, but it does give you more control over your financial destiny.
In this guide, we'll cover:
How much money could stock option planning save you?
Start your planning by understanding what you already have
How to plan your stock options at each stage
Review your stock option planning during these company milestones
A few things to consider when planning your stock options
Non-recourse financing: How to exercise stock options without using your own money
How Secfi can help with stock option planning
How Randy and Lily built a plan for their equity and saved money on taxes with Secfi
Note: Secfi helps employees and executives understand and act on their equity. Try our free AI equity assistant Maeve to start your stock option planning.
While the exact figure will vary, many of our clients come to us because they recognize that intentional stock option planning has the power to create generational wealth.
If your company has a successful exit or liquidity event, you may be able to increase the returns on your equity by:
Giving yourself more time to prepare for a tender offer, acquisition, or IPO before the paperwork arrives.
Qualifying for better tax treatment by starting the ISO holding period earlier, where appropriate.
Spreading the cost and taxes over time by exercising portions of a grant across multiple tax years.
Managing AMT exposure by modeling how many ISOs to exercise in a given tax year.
Reducing the taxable amount at exercise by acting while the difference between the strike price and 409A valuation is smaller.
Avoiding being forced into a rushed decision after leaving the company and facing a short exercise window.
Preserving possible QSBS eligibility by identifying the opportunity early enough to act.
If some (or none) of that makes sense to you, don't worry. That's one of the reasons startup employees avoid stock option planning; it can be like learning a new language. And there are a lot of calculations involved that make DIY spreadsheets a bit risky and prone to errors.
That's why we built Maeve, a free AI equity assistant that can help answer all of these questions. Instead of just explaining them in generic terms, you can connect to your equity data directly and get plain-English insights and explanations for your stock option planning.
For illustrative purposes only. Actual results may vary and there is no guarantee of any particular outcome.
Throughout this article, we'll share some questions you can ask Maeve and see what it suggests for your situation.
It sounds basic, but we often start meetings with clients who aren't sure if they have ISOs, NSOs, or RSUs. Sometimes, their options have already expired because they didn't check the expiration dates.
These details determine which strategies are available, and can help you optimize costs. They can also differ between grants, so don't assume that everything in your equity package follows the same terms.
Start by confirming:
Your equity type: Whether each grant contains Incentive Stock Options (ISOs), NSOs (Non-Qualified Stock Options), or RSUs (Restricted Stock Units).
How many options you can exercise: Your vesting schedule and current vested balance.
Your strike price and current 409A valuation: The figures used to estimate the purchase cost and potential taxes.
Your expiration dates and post-termination window: When your right to exercise could end.
Whether early exercise is allowed: And whether it could require an 83(b) election within 30 days of the early exercise.
We've written a full article on what you should confirm about your existing shares here: What information do I need when exercising stock options?
Maeve Tip: Maeve can connect directly to Carta, or review uploaded equity documents to help organize your grant information and confirm the details you need for decision-making.
Ideally, stock option planning starts when you receive your grant, not when an IPO is announced or an exercise deadline is a few weeks away.
We find it helpful to treat stock option planning as a series of stages. At each stage, figure out what's changed, rerun the numbers, and decide whether you need to act or simply keep preparing.
Start by understanding exactly what you have, including your option type, vesting schedule, expiration date, and the rules in your grant agreement.
You usually don't need to make an immediate exercise decision. However, this is the time to find out whether your company allows early exercise, since that can create a separate planning path.
Early exercise means buying options before they vest, and may be more relevant while your company's fair market value is still close to your strike price. It has benefits, but comes with its own tax rules.
Learn more in When should you exercise your stock options?
You may not be able to exercise during your first year of working at a company because your options might not have vested yet.
Planning in the months before your vesting cliff gives you time to fully understand the costs and prepare your finances. We find it's pretty rare for employees to plan this far ahead, but it can make a big difference in your stock option planning.
Read more about your vesting cliff in: What is a stock option vesting schedule?
Once options vest, you gain the right to exercise them. You don't have to exercise immediately, but you now have an active decision to revisit.
Start by estimating the full cost. This may include both the strike price and taxes, depending on whether you have ISOs or NSOs.
This is a good time to consider a staged strategy, such as exercising 5,000 shares in one tax year and another 5,000 the following year (this is just an example; check with a professional for your own details).
If you decide to exercise but don't have the cash, we'll talk about how non-recourse financing can help shortly.
Your first exercise decision doesn't need to become your permanent strategy.
As your company grows, its 409A valuation may rise. Your strike price for an existing grant usually stays fixed, so a higher valuation can create a larger taxable spread and make exercising more expensive.
Your personal circumstances may change too. You might get a raise, build more savings, take on a mortgage, start a family, or receive more equity grants with different terms.
At least once a year, and whenever something important changes like your company's 409A valuation, update your assumptions and compare different exercise timelines. You can also consider different financing options, such as exercising some options with cash and some with external financing.
If you're thinking about leaving your company, it's better to think about exercising sooner rather than later.
Some employees have only a short window after departure, often around 90 days, although the exact period depends on the company and grant agreement. A deadline can turn a decision you have avoided for years into one you need to make in weeks.
For more detail, read What happens to stock options when you leave a company?
After exercising, keep records of your exercise information. You may need these details to calculate your cost basis and taxable gain when you eventually sell.
ISO holders should also track each grant and exercise date. Meeting the required holding periods can affect whether part of the gain is taxed as ordinary income or receives more favorable capital gains treatment. If exercising your ISOs results in AMT, those records may also help you calculate and claim a potential AMT credit in future tax years.
| Stage | What to review | Possible next step |
|---|---|---|
1. When you receive your grant | Option type, strike price, vesting schedule, expiration date, and whether early exercise is allowed | Learn the terms and decide whether early exercise is worth exploring |
2. Before your first vesting cliff | Expected vested amount, 409A valuation, exercise cost, possible taxes, and available cash | Prepare financially and model what exercising after the cliff could look like |
3. As your options vest | Full exercise cost, AMT or ordinary income tax, company outlook, and personal risk tolerance | Exercise all, exercise part, wait, or consider a staged approach |
4. As the company and your finances change | New 409A valuations, additional grants, income, savings, debt, and concentration risk | Update the plan and compare exercising now with waiting |
5. Before leaving the company | Vested balance, post-termination exercise period, tax impact, and funding options | Decide what to exercise before or after departure and what you may let expire |
6. After exercising | Cost basis, holding periods, AMT records, potential AMT credits, and future sale considerations | Keep records and continue monitoring concentration and liquidity options |
You might not know about an upcoming funding round or acquisition until your company announces it. But employees often receive smaller signals about how the business is developing, such as an updated 409A valuation or revenue milestones shared at an all-hands meeting.
These milestones don't automatically mean you need to change directions, but they're good prompts to revisit your stock option plan. They may change the numbers or give you new information to consider.
Maeve tip: If any of these happen at your company, plug the details into Maeve to see how it could impact your different stock option planning scenarios.
When your company raises a new round, investors generally buy preferred shares at a negotiated price. That price is not the same as the 409A valuation of the common shares employees can purchase, although the round may lead to a new 409A valuation and change the estimated cost of exercising.
Later rounds, such as a Series C or Series D, may suggest the company is becoming more mature, but they don't guarantee an IPO, acquisition, or profitable outcome.
Once the round is announced, review whether the 409A valuation changed, whether employees received any liquidity, and whether the company's growth or exit plans look different from before. Companies may also impose a temporary blackout period during a fundraising process, which could prevent you from exercising until the round is complete.
Private companies generally update their 409A valuation at least annually and may need a new one after a material event, such as a funding round. Once the new valuation takes effect, the cost of exercising may look different from the scenario you previously modeled.
A higher 409A valuation may increase the taxable spread when you exercise. For NSOs, that can mean more ordinary income; for ISOs, it can increase the AMT adjustment.
A lower 409A valuation may reduce the taxable spread, although it may also reflect a decline in the company's outlook.
Not every useful signal comes from a formal transaction. Management may share that the company has reached a revenue target, become profitable, signed a major customer, entered a new market, or hit another important operating milestone.
These updates don't guarantee that your shares will increase in value or that a liquidity event is approaching. But they can still help you reassess the company's prospects, how much personal cash you're comfortable risking, and whether your current stock option plan still fits.
A tender offer, company buyback, or approved secondary sale may let eligible employees sell some private-company shares before an IPO or acquisition. Participation can be limited, and you may have only a short time to decide whether to sell, how many shares to use, and whether you need to exercise options first.
The proceeds could create cash, reduce concentration of your worth in the company, or help cover exercise costs and taxes. However, selling also means giving up the potential future upside on those shares, so compare the immediate benefit with what you would continue to own afterward.
An acquisition can affect vested and unvested options in different ways. Depending on the transaction and your grant terms, your options may be assumed by the buyer, converted into new equity, accelerated, cashed out, or cancelled.
Don't rely on the transaction headline alone. The details in your grant agreement and acquisition documents determine what happens to your equity.
An IPO may make it easier to sell shares or use a cashless exercise, but it can also come after the company's 409A valuation and estimated exercise taxes have risen.
Review the cost of exercising before versus after the listing, any ISO holding periods, employee lockups, and how much company stock you would want to keep once liquidity becomes available.
An IPO isn't guaranteed to happen on schedule, and the share price can fall after listing. So weigh the greater certainty and liquidity of waiting against the possibility of higher exercise costs.
Not every milestone reflects growth. A company may raise capital at a lower valuation, reprice outstanding stock options, conduct layoffs, or change its strategy.
A lower 409A valuation might reduce the estimated tax cost of exercising, but it can also indicate greater company risk. An option repricing could make an underwater grant more attractive, while a restructuring may affect your confidence in the company or your expected time there.
In these cases, avoid focusing on the lower exercise cost alone. Reconsider the company's prospects, your job stability, the amount you already have invested, and whether you're comfortable increasing that exposure.
Even after all that, there are still more considerations. Before deciding what to do, make sure the strategy also fits your wider finances and potential tax treatment.
Consider how much personal risk you can afford to take. Exercising means putting money into one illiquid private company, so review your emergency fund, debt, major expenses, retirement savings, and existing exposure to your employer. You may decide to exercise only a portion or set a firm limit on how much personal cash you are prepared to risk.
Estimate whether exercising could trigger AMT. Exercising and holding ISOs can create an alternative minimum tax adjustment based partly on the spread between your strike price and the shares' fair market value. That could leave you owing tax before you've sold the shares or received any cash.
Check whether the shares could qualify for QSBS treatment. Eligible qualified small business stock may receive favorable federal capital gains treatment after the required holding period and if the relevant rules are met. It is most often relevant to founders and very early employees, and potential eligibility should be treated as one planning factor rather than a guarantee.
Once you know how many options you want to exercise, you need to account for both the strike price and any potential taxes.
You may be able to use your own cash, sometimes take out a loan, sell eligible shares, or wait for a cashless exercise.
Each approach has different implications for your cash flow, taxes, personal liability, and future ownership.
Another way to exercise is with non-recourse financing. It can provide the money needed to cover the exercise price and associated taxes, without monthly repayments or putting your personal assets at risk.
If your company has a successful exit, you repay the financed amount and applicable fees. If there is no successful exit or the shares become worthless, the financed amount generally doesn't have to be repaid. This can help you preserve cash while continuing to participate in potential future upside.
It also doesn't typically impact your debt-to-income ratio, which can help you out if you're looking to secure loans or a mortgage for other life goals.
For a full comparison, read How to pay for your stock options.
Secfi was founded in 2017 by startup employees who faced difficult equity decisions themselves. Since then, we've worked with founders and employees across many of the country's leading private companies and provided more than $800 million in financing to help startup employees exercise their stock options.
As more companies stay private longer, we're seeing startup employees with equity worth potentially 13 times their annual salaries. Planning for that kind of gap takes people who understand the implications, both on a tax level and a personal level.
Here's why employees at DoorDash, Reddit, and Databricks work with Secfi:
Maeve is Secfi's AI equity assistant. It brings Secfi's equity planning tools together in one place, so you can connect your Carta account or upload equity documents and ask questions based on your own grants.
Maeve can help you understand your option type and grant terms, estimate exercise costs and taxes, and compare possibilities such as exercising now, waiting, or exercising in stages. You can update the information and rerun the scenarios as your options vest, your company's 409A valuation changes, or a company event approaches.
It also includes current 409A valuations for thousands of private companies, with the data updated as new information becomes available. You can check and adjust its assumptions too, so the scenarios better reflect your actual grant, finances, and view of the company.
For illustrative purposes only. Actual results may vary and there is no guarantee of any particular outcome.
Stock options rarely exist in isolation. Exercising may affect your savings, taxes, investment concentration, and family plans.
Secfi Wealth gives you access to financial planners who understand private-company equity and can help you build a stock option plan within that wider financial picture. The Wealth team can help you think through how much personal cash you can reasonably risk, whether to exercise in stages, how your equity affects diversification, and how to prepare for a possible liquidity event.
For many tax advisors and planners, startup equity is mostly theoretical. But our team works with stock options and equity planning every day. Our experience means we know what to look out for, so you can feel comfortable with the decisions you make.
Secfi Wealth planners have fiduciary duties to their clients, meaning they're required to put the client's interests first when providing advice. Either way, make sure to ask these five questions to a financial planner before choosing one to advise on your equity.
When exercising appears to make sense but the upfront cost is too high, Secfi's non-recourse financing can help eligible employees. Our non-recourse funding covers the strike price and associated taxes without requiring monthly repayments or putting your other personal assets on the line. Your car, home, and savings aren't used as collateral.
If your company completes a successful liquidity event, you repay the financed amount and applicable fees. If no qualifying exit occurs or the financed shares become worthless, you generally don't repay the financing from your other assets.
Secfi's equity strategists work specifically with employees exploring financing. They can explain eligibility, terms, fees, and possible scenarios.
To learn more about how it works, read: How Secfi financing works – our business model explained.
Randy had already exercised some of his dbt Labs ISOs when he realized that better timing could have reduced his AMT exposure.
As he continued vesting more options, he and his wife, Lily, wanted help understanding how their startup equity, public-company RSUs, cash flow, student loans, savings, and estate planning fit together.
Secfi helped them create a structured financial plan and use some of Lily's vested HubSpot shares to fund additional exercises of Randy's lower-strike-price ISOs. The team also coordinated with an estate planner so their equity was accounted for in plans for their children.
After their first conversation with their Secfi advisor, Randy said, "I just breathed for the first time in probably six, seven months."
Testimonials are specific to an individual Client's experience and may not be representative of all Clients. Unless otherwise indicated, Clients offering a Testimonial do not receive compensation and their statement does not present a conflict of interest.
Stock option planning can't guarantee that your equity will pay off, but it means you can more comfortably change your plan whenever there are major changes in your life or company.
The earlier you understand the numbers, the easier it is to compare different scenarios before a higher valuation or short deadline makes the decision more expensive.
Give Maeve a try to model your equity and explore possible scenarios. For personalized support, you can also reach out to Secfi's team today.
Stock option planning is the process of understanding your equity compensation, what it could cost to exercise, what taxes may apply, and how different choices could affect your wider finances.
For startup employees, that may include reviewing your option type, strike price, vesting period, 409A valuation, expiration date, post-termination exercise period, and possible company events. It also means comparing whether to exercise now, wait, or exercise in stages rather than treating the decision as a one-time calculation.
Secfi's AI equity assistant, Maeve, can help organize your grant details, estimate exercise costs and taxes, and model different stock option planning scenarios.
Ideally, you should begin planning when you receive your grant. At that stage, you can confirm what type of options you have, whether early exercise is available, how long your vesting period lasts, when your options vest, and when they expire.
You should then revisit your plan as options vest, the company's 409A valuation changes, you receive another equity compensation grant, or a company event such as a funding round, tender offer, acquisition, or IPO approaches. It is especially important to review your options before leaving the company because your post-termination exercise period may give you limited time to act.
Secfi's free AI equity assistant, Maeve, can help you update the numbers as your equity, company, and personal circumstances change.
Exercising or selling stock options can create a taxable event and affect both your immediate tax liability and what you keep after eventually selling the shares.
When you exercise NSOs, the difference between the strike price and fair market value is generally included in your gross income and taxed as ordinary income. Exercising and holding ISOs may trigger the alternative minimum tax, which can leave you with a tax liability before you have sold the shares or received cash from them.
Your exercise and sale dates may also affect whether gains qualify for long-term capital gains treatment. Secfi's Maeve can help estimate the tax impact of different scenarios, but stock option taxes depend on your individual circumstances, so consider consulting a qualified tax professional before making a decision.
There is no strategy that is right for everyone. Exercising all at once may start holding periods sooner and could make sense when the taxable spread is relatively small, but it requires more upfront cash and puts more money at risk in one private company.
Exercising portions of a grant over several years can spread out the cash required and may help manage your AMT exposure and wider tax liability, depending on your situation. Waiting preserves cash and gives you more information about the company, but the 409A valuation and estimated exercise cost could rise.
Maeve is an AI equity assistant that can help you compare exercising all at once, exercising in stages, or waiting using your own equity details and assumptions.
Depending on your company and circumstances, you may be able to use personal savings, borrow money, sell shares through an approved tender offer or secondary transaction, wait for a cashless exercise, or combine multiple approaches. Remember that the total amount needed may include both the strike price and any associated tax liability.
Secfi also offers non-recourse financing to eligible employees. It can cover the exercise price and associated taxes without monthly repayments or putting your other personal assets at risk. If the company has a successful exit, you repay the amount financed and applicable fees. If the company does not exit or the financed shares become worthless, you generally do not repay the financing from your other assets.
Non-recourse financing has costs and is not right for every employee. Secfi's equity strategists can explain the eligibility requirements, terms, fees, and potential outcomes.
The tool shown here uses artificial intelligence and is for illustrative purposes only and not necessarily indicative of future results and there is no guarantee that similar results can be achieved. The information provided by the tool is not professional advice and is not intended by Secfi, Inc., its affiliates, and Secfi representatives, to be deemed as investment, legal, tax or other professional advice or recommendations of any kind, or to form the basis of any decision to do or to refrain from doing anything. Secfi does not review the accuracy or completeness of the information provided to us within the tool.